| # | Name | Position | Height | Weight | Class | Home Town / School |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Cannon, Andy | OF | 5-8 | 165lb. | 2010 | LaGrange, IL / Lyons Twp |
| 2 | Ludwig, Dan | OF/P | 5-7 | 170lb. | 2011 | Victor, NY / Victor |
| 5 | Fuke, Blayne | INF | 5-8 | 150lb. | 2010 | Kailua, HI / Mid-Pacific Institute |
| 6 | Sullivan, Ryan | C | 6-0 | 175lb. | 2009 | Hilton, NY / Hilton |
| 7 | Stein, Nathan | SS | 6-1 | 170lb. | 2010 | Rochester, NY / Greece Odyssey |
| 8 | Chanatry, Charles | P | 5-11 | 165lb. | 2011 | Jamesville, NY / Fabius-Pompey |
| 9 | Cacciola, Nick | P/DH | 5-10 | 160lb. | 2011 | Northport, NY / Northport |
| 12 | Caruso, Dominick | OF | 5-8 | 175lb. | 2012 | Liverpool, NY / Liverpool |
| 15 | Brien, Dan | 1B | 5-11 | 185lb. | 2009 | Liverpool, NY / Liverpool |
| 16 | Wexler, Michael | P | 6-0 | 175lb. | 2011 | Rye, NY / Rye Neck |
| 17 | Barnard, Robby | UTIL | 5-11 | 175lb. | 2012 | Springfield, VA / St. Stephen- St. Agnes |
| 18 | Guzski, Steven | P | 6-0 | 195lb. | 2010 | New Hartford, NY / New Hartford |
| 20 | Just, Steve | C | 6-0 | 185lb. | 2011 | Liverpool, NY / Liverpool |
| 21 | Park, Michael | P | 6-1 | 180lb. | 2009 | Scarsdale, NY / Scarsdale |
| 22 | Parker, Alex | INF | 6-4 | 195lb. | 2012 | Coral Springs, FL / University School |
| 23 | Toland, Paul | P | 6-1 | 185lb. | 2009 | S. Weymouth, MA / Boston Coll. HS |
| 24 | Bezek, Brian | 2B/SS | 6-1 | 170lb. | 2012 | Rochester, NY / Penfield |
| 25 | Piehler, Dan | C | 6-1 | 190lb. | 2012 | Rochester, NY / Gates-Chili |
| 26 | Caghan, Alex | SS/P | 6-1 | 180lb. | 2012 | North Canton, OH / Jackson |
| 27 | Storme, Casey | C | 6-0 | 170lb. | 2012 | Palo Cedro, CA / Foothill |
| 28 | Schwartz, D.J. | P | 6-1 | 217lb. | 2012 | Arkport, NY / Hornell |
| 29 | Francis, Matt | OF | 6-0 | 185lb. | 2011 | East Amherst, NY / Clarence |
| 30 | Brocks, Luke | P | 6-4 | 200lb. | 2010 | Moon Twp., PA / Sewickley |