The G. Graydon Curtis '58 and Jane W. Curtis Award for Nontenured Faculty Teaching is intended for faculty who are on the tenure track but who have not yet achieved tenure. Past recipients are:
| YEAR | RECIPIENT | DEPARTMENT |
| 2012 | Karen DeAngelis | Educational Leadership |
| 2011 | Eleana Kim | Anthropology |
| 2010 | Andrew Wall | Educational Leadership |
| 2009 | Jason Middleton | English |
| 2008 | April Luehmann | Teaching & Curriculum |
| 2007 | Nancy Ares | Teaching & Curriculum |
| 2006 | Matthew BaileyShea | Music Theory |
| 2005 | Jeffrey Tucker | English |
| 2004 | Curtis Signorino | Political Science |
| 2003 | Wendi Heinzelman | Electrical & Computer Engineering |
| 2002 | Randall Halle | Modern Languages & Cultures |
| 2001 | Anne Merideth | Religion & Classics |
| 2000 | Brian Brent | Warner School |
| 1999 | Lynne Orr | Physics & Astronomy |
| 1998 | Edna Seidmann | Simon School |
| 1997 | Melanie Manion | Political Science |
| 1996 | Julia B. Smith | Warner School |
| 1995 | Frank Wolfs | Physics & Astronomy |
| 1994 | Stephen Hutchings | Modern Languages & Cultures |
| 1993 | Emil Homerin | Religion & Classics |