Academic Misconduct
Academic Misconduct Process
Overview
Each school will have a written policy on academic misconduct on file with the school’s graduate dean or designee (school official who oversees graduate education). Each school will have a designated panel to review the charge of academic misconduct. A school’s written policy may call for graduate student representation on the panel.
All events, documents related to suspected misconduct, and statements from involved parties should be thoroughly and accurately documented, with careful attention to maintaining confidentiality and upholding the integrity of the investigative process. Schools may develop forms for this purpose.
As stated above, academic misconduct matters shall be reviewed by the appropriate associate dean or designee. Reports of potential misconduct will either:
- Be dismissed;
- Reach administrative resolution (described below); or
- Be sent to the school’s panel, as elaborated upon below.
Some academic misconduct incidents may reach administrative resolution facilitated by the school’s graduate dean or designee. Administrative resolution is limited to first violations in which the student(s) alleged to have committed the violation, the student victims if any, and the faculty member(s) reporting the incident agree on the events that occurred, the nature and seriousness of the misconduct, and the proposed sanction. Documentation is submitted to the graduate dean or designee, who may approve the proposed sanction and communicate this to the parties involved or may opt to refer the case to the panel. In either case, they will communicate this to the parties involved. In handling cases through administrative resolution without panel involvement, graduate deans or designees must ensure that the student admitted responsibility without coercion and that the proposed sanction is appropriate to the violation and comparable to other penalties for similar violations. Expulsion is not an appropriate sanction in cases of administrative resolution.
Outline of Steps for Academic Misconduct Process Link to section
Step 1: Reporting the Incident
- The instructor records evidence of possible misconduct according to school procedure and reports the incident to graduate dean or designee.
Step 2: Review by Graduate Dean or Designee
- The graduate dean or designee receives the report of potential academic misconduct, reviews the material, and/or meets with those involved.
Possible Outcomes:
A. Case Dismissed
- If, after reviewing all relevant information, the graduate dean or designee determines that academic misconduct did not occur, the case is dismissed.
B. Administrative Resolution
- Schools may allow administrative resolution by the graduate dean or designee for first violations if the student alleged, students impacted, and reporting faculty agree on the facts of the incident and the proposed sanction.
- The decision and sanction are not final until approved by the graduate dean or designee.
- The graduate dean or designee maintains records of all incidents resolved in this manner.
Step 3: Determination of Academic Misconduct
- The graduate dean or designee determines if the matter should be treated as academic misconduct and does not qualify for administrative resolution.
Special Cases:
- If the alleged academic misconduct involves sponsored research, threatens the integrity of the scientific method, or compromises the creation of new knowledge, the incident will be referred to the relevant University body handling scientific or research misconduct.
- These cases will follow procedures as specified by the Policy on Research Misconduct under the Office of the Vice President for Research - Integrity and Compliance.
Step 4: Conduct Panel Hearing
- Charges are referred to the conduct panel in the student's school.
- The panel conducts a hearing, makes findings, presents supporting documents, and provides a recommendation.
Step 5: Decision and Sanction
- The graduate dean or designee issues the decision and sanction to the student.
Possible Outcomes:
A. Decision Accepted
- The student accepts the decision.
B. Appeal Process
- The student may appeal the decision to the Dean of the School within seven days of receiving the decision.
Appeal Outcomes:
A. Decision Modified
- The Dean of the School modifies the decision.
B. Decision Upheld
- The Dean of the School upholds the decision.