Policies Concerning the PhD Degree
PhD Dissertation
Pre-Dissertation Link to section
Qualifying Examination Link to section
All PhD students must take a Qualifying Examination (QE) to demonstrate they are prepared to advance to candidacy, undertake independent research, and begin the dissertation. All PhD programs administer a qualifying examination as part of the PhD program requirements. The qualifying examination may be either written, oral, or both, at the discretion of the department/program, and must be passed at least six months before the dissertation oral defense is taken. The appropriate associate dean appoints the committee to conduct a qualifying examination which consists of at least three full-time faculty (four for the School of Medicine and Dentistry). A vote to pass the candidate must be approved by a majority of the designated members of the committee. The votes of all committee members are recorded. The office of the associate dean must be notified at least two weeks before a qualifying examination is to be held, and passage or failure must be reported within one month after the examination. After a failure, a second qualifying examination may be taken if in accordance with program or school policy. A third examination may be taken only upon the recommendation of the appropriate Committee on Graduate Education and with the approval of the associate dean or equivalent. In the School of Nursing and the School of Medicine and Dentistry, a third examination is not given.
Admission to Candidacy Link to section
Attaining candidacy status signifies a doctoral student’s attainment of a level of proficiency within a discipline that enables the generation of an original research contribution in their field. The certification by the associate dean of a school, following the successful completion of the qualifying examination, officially designates the student as a candidate for the PhD degree. At the request of the candidate, the University dean of graduate education is authorized to issue a certificate validating this significant academic milestone.
Dissertation Advisory Committee Link to section
The pivotal role of the dissertation advisory committee lies in guiding the candidate through the intricate process of preparing the dissertation for the final oral defense. Central to its purpose is the facilitation of the dissertation project’s development and the critical evaluation of the dissertation’s acceptability in fulfilling the stringent requirements for the doctoral degree. Committee members collectively shoulder the responsibility of ensuring the candidate produces scholarship of the highest caliber. This involves advising the student on research conduct, meticulously reviewing drafts of the dissertation, and offering insightful suggestions for potential enhancements. The constitution of the dissertation committee is carefully designed to provide both independent evaluation and expert guidance on the dissertation.
Formation of the dissertation advisory committee occurs at least six months prior to the scheduled oral defense. This lead time is strategically allotted to facilitate comprehensive discussions on the dissertation, ensuring a thorough and collaborative preparation process.
In this document, a ‘program’ refers to the graduate faculty capable of advising on a dissertation within a specific academic subject of the PhD degree. In certain instances, the term “program” is used interchangeably with “department,” particularly in cases where the department exclusively houses a single PhD program, but for interdisciplinary programs and departments that house more than one PhD program, it is more complex. In interdisciplinary degree programs with faculty from multiple departments, the school hosting the program defines ‘internal’ and ‘external’ for the final oral examination committee. In departments that house more than one PhD program, the school hosting the program defines ‘internal’ and ‘external’ for the final oral examination committee.
Dissertation Link to section
The submission of a dissertation stands as an imperative requirement for the conferral of the PhD degree. A dissertation is a formal document or scholarly product wherein a candidate meticulously presents their original research contribution. While the content of the dissertation adheres to the scholarly standards of the specific discipline and is guided by the dissertation committee, the candidate assumes a primary role in conducting the research and authoring the dissertation. The final phases of the doctoral degree completion process fall under the purview of the University Office of Graduate Education and Postdoctoral Affairs. These phases encompass the preparation of the dissertation for oral defense, the actual conduct of the oral defense, and the subsequent submission of the final copy of the dissertation.
Policy on Generative A.I. in the Dissertation Link to section
Students intending to utilize generative AI tools in their dissertation, thesis, capstone project or culminating experience must consistently obtain and formally document unambiguous approval for the intended uses in advance from their supervisor(s) and supervisory committee.
Innovative uses of generative AI, such as predictive text and image generation, can enhance scholarly activities and research integrity, while graduate students and faculty uphold high academic standards. Therefore, the utilization of generative AI tools in the process of doctoral dissertation and master’s thesis research and writing, master’s capstone projects, or culminating experiences must always occur with full transparency. This includes providing a description of any employment of generative AI in the research or writing process, along with appropriate citation. Students are required to include a disclaimer in their dissertation, such as: ‘Generative AI was used for XYZ [listing tasks such as writing text, generating code for graphs, etc.].
If generative AI is utilized, it also becomes the student’s responsibility to ensure that any sources potentially utilized by the AI, without citation, are properly cited within the student’s work.
Unauthorized or unacknowledged use of generative AI tools for scholarly graduate work at the University of Rochester may be considered an offence under the Academic Integrity Policy (see section in these Regulations and University Policies Concerning Graduate Studies) and the University Policy on Misconduct in Scholarship and Research.
Note: Schools may have more stringent guidelines.
Warning: Commercial products (i.e. ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini) bears the risk of the data being considered public domain and generated material can’t be copyrighted without transformative human input.
See also https://www.rochester.edu/provost/gen-ai-education/
Dissertation Oral Defense Link to section
The oral defense of the dissertation represents the institutional commitment to rigorously assess a candidate’s scholarly contributions and ascertain their fulfillment of the requirements for the PhD degree. This pivotal event marks the culmination of a candidate’s doctoral studies, serving as the paramount intellectual encounter wherein discerning individuals dedicate meticulous attention to the candidate’s ideas and/or body of work.
The appointment of the Dissertation Oral Defense Committee is sanctioned by the University Dean of Graduate Education, guided by the counsel of the relevant Associate Dean of Graduate Education. Typically, this committee comprises the members of the original Dissertation Advisory Committee that oversaw the candidate’s thesis research.
The constitution of the Dissertation Oral Defense Committee necessitates the inclusion of the following individuals; each vested with the authority to cast a vote during the dissertation oral defense.
The constitution of the Dissertation Oral Defense Committee adheres to the following criteria, ensuring a comprehensive and impartial evaluation.
Voting Membership Limit Link to section
The committee may have a maximum of five members with voting rights. However, additional members, without voting privileges, are permitted to participate in the proceedings. Please see notes below regarding co-advisors.
Internal Faculty Members Link to section
A minimum of two faculty members internal to the program at the University of Rochester. One of which is the advisor. If the student has two advisors, they will both serve as internal members of the committee, regardless of appointment.
External Faculty Member Link to section
At least one faculty member external to the program, hailing from either the University of Rochester or another accredited university.
Chair of the Dissertation Oral Defense Link to section
A faculty member from the University of Rochester, external to the program, and without a significant scholarly relationship with the candidate or other committee members, will preside as the chair during the dissertation oral defense. The chair is considered neutral party and is neither an internal nor external member of the committee.
Ratio of Internal to External Members Link to section
The ratio of external to internal committee members with voting privileges should not exceed 50 percent. This stipulation ensures that either an equivalent number or a majority of committee members are internal to the program or department.
Based on the criteria above, there are three options for voting committee composition.
- Two internal members, one of which is the advisor, and one external member and the chair – 4 voting members.
- Two internal members, one of which is the advisor, and two external members and –e chair – 5 voting members.
- Three internal members, one of which is the advisor, and one external member and the chair – 5 voting members.
For co-advised students:
- Two co-advisors (both internal), one external member, and the chair – 4 voting members.
- Two co-advisors (both internal), one additional internal member, one external member, and the chair – 5 voting members.
- Two co-advisors (both internal), two external members, and the chair – 5 voting members.
- Two co-advisors (both internal) one additional internal member, two external members, and the chair – 6 voting members.
To view an illustration of these committees, we have developed a committee matrix: https://www.rochester.edu/graduate-education/phd-students/phd-completion-process/committee-matrix/.
These guidelines have been established to guarantee a judicious and balanced assessment of the candidate’s work during the dissertation oral defense.
In the context of dissertation advisory or oral defense committees, the term “faculty” pertains to individuals holding an earned doctorate and occupying a full-time, tenured or tenure-eligible position at the rank of professor, associate professor, or assistant professor within an accredited university. University of Rochester faculty members, encompassing instructional, clinical, emeritus, and research roles, may seek inclusion on the petition-approved roster of faculty eligible to participate in PhD dissertation committees by petitioning* the University Dean of Graduate Education (Link to petition: https://forms.office.com/r/b2SK8MGZBQ).
Some petitions happen infrequently and do not have a documented practice in place. Therefore, an email petition is required. The email petition should include relevant information to the request. Other petitions, because of their frequency, have a formalized process, by which a form needs to be completed with very specific questions that need to be answered. Those petitions which have a process defined are noted in this document with an asterisk (*).
Key points regarding the composition and roles of the committee include:
Chair
The pivotal role of overseeing the final oral examination committee is entrusted to the University Dean of Graduate Education or a designated representative, who assumes the position of chair. The chair’s responsibility encompasses the vigilant promotion of fairness and rigor throughout the defense proceedings. Distanced from affiliations with the advisor’s and student’s working group, program, the chair’s impartial stance minimizes pre-existing judgments on the candidate’s work and mitigates administrative influence in the defense process. Notably, the chair holds voting membership status within the final oral examination committee. This role is ineligible for petitions.
Primary Dissertation Advisor
The primary dissertation advisor must be a tenured or tenure-eligible faculty member at the University of Rochester, holding the rank of professor, associate professor, or assistant professor. Irrespective of their primary appointment, the dissertation advisor is always an internal member. However, they are ineligible to serve as the chairperson of the final oral defense or as the external member of the oral defense committee for their advisee.
Dissertation Co-advisor
If there is a co-advisor, The dissertation co-advisor must be a tenured or tenure-eligible faculty member, holding the rank of professor, associate professor, or assistant professor. Irrespective of their primary appointment, the dissertation advisor is always an internal member. However, they are ineligible to serve as the chairperson of the final oral defense or as the external member of the oral defense committee.
Sixth Member for Co-Advised Students Link to section
When a student has formally appointed co-advisors, both individuals count toward the required committee membership. In these cases, the committee may include six members, with one co-advisor effectively serving as the sixth. This structure supports disciplinary breadth and meets representation requirements (e.g., external department or area of expertise). No special approval is required; the full committee, including both co-advisors, should be documented on the standard committee composition form.
Internal Committee Members
The committee’s internal members play a vital role in guaranteeing the thoroughness and adherence of the candidate’s dissertation defense to program requirements. These members, who have in-depth knowledge of doctoral-level training, research, and scholarship in the candidate’s research area, must hold their primary appointment in the University program offering the PhD program or be core University faculty designated for an interdisciplinary PhD program. However, it’s important to note that the advisor/co-advisor policy takes precedence over this general policy.
External Member
The external member is required to have expertise in the candidate’s research field, enabling them to comprehend, critique, and contribute to the dissertation’s quality and significance. This member may not hold their primary appointment in the University program offering the PhD. Candidates are encouraged to include an external member from outside the University of Rochester. Such individuals must petition* to be on the committee during the registration of the oral defense (Link to petition: https://forms.office.com/r/NWnFURXUUx).
Continuation of Service for Departing Faculty Link to section
Faculty members who leave a program, or the University, may serve as internal members on a PhD dissertation committee for up to 36 months from their date of departure. If the program wishes a faculty member departing from the university to continue serving as an internal committee member, the program should retain the individual in an appropriate affiliated status (e.g., adjunct or temporary academic appointment) and provide a modest stipend or compensation consistent with institutional policy.
To serve during this period, all the following are required:
- The faculty member served on the student’s qualifying exam committee or dissertation advisory committee before leaving the program.
- The program director approves the faculty member as an internal committee member.
- The faculty member meets any additional requirements set by the school.
- The faculty member has a written agreement on file with the program at the time of departure. This agreement must be included in the dissertation approval process.
Objective Evaluation and Professional Relationships Link to section
To ensure an unbiased assessment of the dissertation, committee members are prohibited from having intimate or close family relationships with each other. Exceptions may be considered only when a documented COI Management plan exists to manage professional relationships, safeguarding the interests of all parties involved. This document is filed at the time of creation of the online record and will be reviewed by the University Graduate Education Office. See the sample COI Management Plan Document for an example.
Additional Members for Enhanced Quality and Rigor Link to section
Beyond the mandatory four members, additional individuals whose inclusion significantly contributes to the quality and rigor of the dissertation research and oral defense are permissible. These members, possessing a doctorate, are not obligated to hold a faculty position, either within the University or elsewhere. Approval for external committee members that are also external to the University must be sought through a petition* to the University Dean of Graduate Education before scheduling the dissertation oral defense. The first of these members will participate with voting privileges, while any subsequent additional members will serve without a vote (link to petition).
Nomination of the Chair for the Final Oral Examination Link to section
In the Schools of Arts & Sciences, Hajim School of Engineering, Medicine and Dentistry, and the Eastman School of Music, the chair is not allowed to hold a primary faculty appointment within the PhD program. In the Schools of Nursing, Warner, and Simon, the chair may be a faculty member within the school but must operate outside the defined area of specialty for both the candidate and the advisor.
The senior official overseeing graduate education within each school is tasked with identifying a chair for every PhD oral defense within that school. The selection process, determined by the school, ensures a school specific approach to chair appointments. Some schools have instituted a policy whereby the selection of the chair occurs either at the program level or at the level of the defending student, with approval flowing from the program, through the school, and subsequently to the University. Please check with your program to verify the process for selecting the chair.
Subsequent to the appointment, the selected individual, the candidate, and other committee members are duly notified. The candidate bears the responsibility of furnishing the chair and all committee members with copies of the dissertation identical to the version submitted for registration, to be utilized during the oral defense.
Registering the PhD Dissertation for the Final Oral Examination Link to section
To initiate the final oral examination process, the PhD candidate must establish a comprehensive record within the University’s online PhD processing system. This record includes details such as the planned defense date and time, committee members, and other pertinent information and if applicable COI Management Plan and non-standard committee members approvals. Simultaneously, all relevant documents, including the dissertation, must be uploaded to this record. Subsequently, online approvals for the dissertation defense are obtained from all inside and outside committee members, the program director, and the school’s graduate office. This crucial step must be completed at least five business days before the defense date, allowing for the requisite final approval from the University Graduate Education office. Review the provided website for guidance on school dissertation timelines and always consult your program to ascertain any supplementary timelines.
Dissertation Defense Scheduling Link to section
Final approval from the University Graduate Education office signifies the formal registration of the dissertation for defense. This approval can be granted on any business day, with the exception of the week between Christmas and New Year’s Day and a designated period in late April, as specified in the PhD calendar distributed to all graduate education officials across schools.
In the event of necessary formatting changes, the office staff in the respective school and University Graduate Education will indicate these changes on a version of the dissertation added to the student’s online PhD defense record.
The final oral examination cannot be conducted until at least five business days have passed since the dissertation’s registration in the Office of the University Dean of Graduate Education. It is the student’s responsibility to align their plans accordingly, and deadlines can be confirmed with the office of the school’s associate dean of graduate education.
In preparation for the registration process, the candidate must distribute copies of the dissertation to all members of the final examination committee at least two weeks before initiating the online registration. Committee members retain the right to decline approval if they have not had at least two weeks for review. Additionally, a copy of the same version must be provided to the appointed dissertation chair. Once the dissertation is registered, no further changes can be distributed to committee members until after the final oral examination, or the examination will be canceled.
Procedures for Final Oral Examination (PhD Dissertation Defense) Link to section
The final oral examination occurs following the completion of all other degree requirements, but not sooner than six months after the qualifying examination. This examination, covering the dissertation subject and the related field, places emphasis on recent and significant developments in the field. Its purpose is to assess the proposal of a substantial thesis in the dissertation and evaluate the candidate’s ability to defend it with appropriate and effective arguments, supported by relevant and convincing evidence.
The presentation and defense of the dissertation serves as the pinnacle of the PhD degree. The final oral examination is not just a judgment on a single scholarly work but implicitly reflects on the overall quality of the candidate’s graduate education. Given its broader significance, the committee must ensure the successful defense of a substantial thesis.
A unanimous vote of approval from the final oral examining committee is required. In the case of a single dissenting vote, the matter will be presented to the University Council on Graduate Education for a decision. A candidate failing the final examination is granted one repeat examination unless a majority vote from the examining committee recommends against it. Regulations for committee structure, timing of registration before defense, and other aspects for a repeat examination mirror those applied to the initial examination.
For candidates passing their defense with no/minor revisions, the revisions must be completed within three months from the defense date. If the defense requires major revisions, these must be completed within six months from the defense date. Delays beyond these time limits necessitate a proposed timeline for completion, which must be reviewed and approved by the University Dean of Graduate Education. Note: schools may have more stringent deadlines.
Remote Defense Policy Link to section
At the discretion of the faculty member responsible for the administration of a PhD program, and with the unanimous agreement of all committee members and the student, oral defense examinations may be conducted either in person or online via high-quality electronic audio and video conferencing. All members of the oral defense committee are expected to participate synchronously. Committee members may participate either live or remotely. If the defense is conducted remotely, instructions for accessing online exams must be made available to all members of the oral defense committee via the PhD Completion system. Therefore, online provisions for the defense must be set at the time of the registration of the PhD Dissertation for the Final Oral Examination.
If held in person, exams must take place on the Eastman School of Music Campus, Medical Center/Middle Campus, Mount Hope Campus, River Campus, South Campus, or at a satellite campus location (including the Memorial Art Gallery).
Post-Defense Link to section
Submission of Final Dissertation Link to section
After successful completion of the final oral examination, the candidate must complete all required final revisions, including formatting changes as indicated by the University graduate education office staff. If the defense committee mandates revisions, the individual designated on the final PhD Oral Examination Report must approve them before submission to the University graduate education office. For major revisions, the University Graduate Education office will ensure that the defense committee's requirements are met by contacting the designated person identified by the committee. The candidate must upload the final, approved dissertation copy to the UMI/ProQuest website and notify the Office of the Dean of Graduate Education upon completion. If the school or program requires paper copies, the candidate must provide them.
Each PhD candidate must also submit a completed authorization form for including the dissertation in UR Research, the University’s digital research repository. The student will receive instructions and the authorization form via email on the next business day after the final oral examination.
The PhD oral defense committee determines whether a candidate passes with no/minor revisions, passes with major revisions, or fails. Candidates who pass with no or minor revisions must complete them within three months of the defense date, while those with major revisions must finish them within six months. The University does not permit delays beyond these limits unless the University Dean of Graduate Education approves a formal request for an extended completion timeline. Note: Schools may enforce stricter deadlines.
Clinical psychology students completing a year-long internship in their final year follow an alternative timeline for submitting their dissertation to ProQuest. However, they must still meet the submission deadlines to remain eligible for their desired degree conferral date. This policy aligns with peer clinical psychology PhD programs.
Dissertation Embargo Policy Link to section
The University of Rochester adheres to open access publishing principles, digitally archiving the completed dissertations of all PhD graduate students. The university archives these dissertations, allowing access via UR Research and has partnered with ProQuest for wider dissemination. Students retain ownership of the copyright for their work.
Students have the option to request an embargo on access to the full text of the dissertation through UR Research at the time of submission to the Office of University Graduate Education and Postdoctoral Affairs. An embargo on full access allows users to view the title, program, URL, and the date when the full text will become available.
At the time of submission, students may choose an initial embargo period of up to two years. Up to two renewals of the embargo period may be granted at the discretion of the Office of University Graduate Education and Postdoctoral Affairs. The total embargo period, including approved renewals, will not exceed six years from the date of submission. Requests for extension must be directed to UnivGradEducation@UR.Rochester.edu.
For those wishing to extend the embargo on their dissertation in ProQuest, contact ProQuest directly. Extensions will be subject to ProQuest’s then-current policy and procedures.