Played on the 1920 and 1921 football teams at right tackle, center, and right guard
Earned Little All-American at right tackle
Heavyweight wrestler, and named captain during his sophomore year
Threw the discus, shot put, and javelin on the track team and competed in the Penn Relays
Two years of interclass and intramural basketball
Captain of interclass baseball
Frosh Frolic Committee
Soph Hop Committee
Soph Joll
Wearer of the R
Post-Graduate:
Forced to leave the UR because of financial reasons after his sophomore year
Signed with the NFL's Rochester Jeffersons in 1923
Received a letter from Pete Rozelle congratulating him as being one of the pioneers of the NFL
Main event boxer and wrestler in Central and Western New York fighting as "Irish Joe McShea" or "Farmer Joey McShea"
Sportswriter George Beahon says of his athletic accomplishments, "McShea's name belongs in the very top echelon of all-time Rochester athletes, amateur or professional."
Inducted into the Section V Football Hall of Fame
Passed away on December 21, 1985 leaving his 2 children and 12 grandchildren